Nathalie Morris leads an accomplished cast with aplomb in Grace Chapple’s hilarious adaptation of E. M. Forster’s 1908 sweeping romance, in which personal passion and societal convention collide.
Morris plays Lucy Honeychurch, who is holidaying in Florence with her chaperone, being her highly strung cousin, Charlotte Bartlett (Hayley McElhinney). Flies could readily use the latter’s open mouth as a landing point. Such is the measure of McElhinney’s expressions at some of the goings on here. Lucy is keen to be let loose, but Charlotte won’t hear of it and tries to keep her on a tight leash.

When Lucy does get the opportunity to explore the city’s beauty, accompanied, and then unexpectedly abandoned, by gossipy novelist Miss Eleanor Lavish (Kate Atkinson), her head is turned. Lucy’s carefully controlled world is thrown off its axis by scrupulously honest George Emerson (Luke Wiltshire), although she dares not succumb to his charms … or perhaps so.

Back in England, an unlikely engagement to most unsuitable, pompous and snobbish old friend Cecil Vyse (Charles Wu) threatens to subjugate Lucy’s voice. While George remains close at hand, not afraid to express how he feels, Lucy’s angst riddled mind continues to churn. So, will she follow life’s path laid out for her or carpe diem (seize the day) and venture forth with joie de vivre (the joy of living)? It is, indeed, a circuitous route to happiness.

Chapple’s adaptation is, at times, riotously funny. Two scenes I can readily point to, that metaphorically bring the house down, involve swimming (without any water) and tennis (without any balls). These are wonderfully choreographed by Elle Evangelista. A couple of actors even tackle their roles with naked abandon.
This is hardly the acclaimed 1985 Merchant Ivory film, although, like the movie, it too leaves a lasting and favourable impression. I love the fact that it is mischief filled and there is a distinct freshness about director Hannah Goodwin’s endeavours.

Nathalie Morris is delightful as Lucy Honeychurch in a part she makes her own. Morris ensures that, we, the audience, experience Honeychurch’s confusion, frustration and growth through her journey. Hayley McElhinney is all about exaggerated looks and indignation in her realisation of Charlotte Bartlett.
Kate Atkinson is headstrong as Miss Eleanor Lavish, and more conciliatory as Mrs Honeychurch, keen to show that she is wanting the best for her children, Lucy and Freddy. Tomas Kantor is energetic as Freddy and lost in translation (complete with cue cards with a difference, in one of the other most noteworthy scenes) as an Italian driver.

Among the fun roles in the piece is that of Reverend Arthur Beebe. As Tom Conroy plays him, he is quite the busybody. Luke Wiltshire carries hope and desire in his portrayal of George Emerson, while Patrick Williams is at pains to espouse liberal values as George’s father. Pretentiousness is the watchword of Charles Wu’s depiction of Lucy Honeychurch’s bad match, Cecil Vyse.

Some lavish costuming is counterpointed with simple set design by set and costume designer Zoe Atkinson. Important in realising the many deliberately stiff and jaunty scenes that constitute the work is composer Grace Ferguson, sound designer Madeleine Picard and lighting designer Amelia Lever-Davidson.

So it is that director Hannah Goodwin has ensured there are no shortage of surprises in this thoroughly entertaining adaptation of A Room with a View. Two hours 40 minutes, including interval, it is playing at Southbank Theatre, The Sumner, until 19th December, 2026.
Alex First
Other reviews you might enjoy:
- Happy Days (MTC) – theatre review
- Laurinda (MTC) – theatre review
- Much Ado About Nothing (MTC), at Southbank Theatre, The Sumner – theatre review

Alex First is the editor of The Blurb. Alex is a Melbourne based journalist and communications specialist. He also contributes to The Blurb on film and theatre.
