X

Watershed: The Death of Dr Duncan, at Playhouse, Arts Centre Melbourne – music theatre review

On 10th May 1972, Dr George Ian Ogilvie Duncan, a University of Adelaide law lecturer, was thrown into the River Torrens, with another man, Roger James. They had been set upon by a group of men at a known meeting spot for homosexuals. While James suffered a broken ankle, 41-year-old Duncan – who was born in London – drowned.

His murder shocked the community, with allegations that three police officers were involved in “poofter bashing”. Duncan’s death became a watershed moment. It prompted change in South Australian legislation, as it became the first state or territory in the country to decriminalise homosexuality. But to this day no-one has ever been convicted of Duncan’s death.

Watershed: The Death of Dr Duncan tells his story and that of the treatment of gay people in the state and this country. It is a sobering and emotional watch, which screams of injustice on many fronts. The work was commissioned five years ago by Adelaide Festival, Feast Festival and the State Opera of South Australia to commemorate the 50th anniversary of Dr Duncan’s demise.

Combining shock value with sensitivity, what composer Joseph Twist, librettists Alan Valentine and Christos Tsiolkas, and director Neil Armfield AO have achieved is remarkable. While deliberately coarse at times, there is a poetic nature about the language used. The fluidity of the music draws inspiration from classical, popular and, even, heavy metal styles.

There is an inherent sadness and yet determination and hope about what is presented. Sitting there watching this unfold, I was upset, angry … outraged.
The material reaches down into the soul – into one’s sense of decency and humanity. The performances and staging are highly appealing. The Opera Australia chorus is positioned either side of the stage, while in the orchestra pit sit members of Orchestra Victoria, conducted by Brett Weymark OAM.

Four principals play key roles. With his rich vocalisation, tenor Mark Oates, who is cast as Dr Duncan and former South Australian Premier Don Dunstan, commands attention. So, too, classical bass Pelham Andrews, who fills three parts, whistleblower policeman Mick O’Shea, another cop and a lawyer. Blake Appleqvist brings sensitivity to a character known as Lost Boy, representing the many unnamed and forgotten victims of anti-gay violence and discrimination.

Sebastian Geilings does an outstanding job as a dancer representing Dr Duncan. He spends much of the operatic oratorio dangling from a cable upside down. Even when he is on terra firma, his carefully choreographed movements are noteworthy. In fact, plaudits to the overall choreography by Lewis Major. Imagery representing the unsolved case, which has stood in infamy, is projected onto a screen at the back of the stage. Sean Bacon is the video designer.

At the front of the stage is a strip of water, a most effective device for the barefooted dancer and the Lost Boy, also sans shoes. The dancer’s loose costuming, his white shirt unbuttoned, contrasts with the more formal attire of the principals and the ensemble. Set and costume designer AiIsa Paterson is to be applauded for her creativity.

The impact of Watershed is heightened by the attention paid to the lighting design by Nigel Levings and Jim Atkins’ sound design. Neil Armfield and revival director Dr Cheryl Pickering have given us every reason to lament, while honouring the life of Dr Duncan. Watershed: The Death of Dr Duncan is a very special piece. Ninety minutes without interval, it is on at Playhouse, Arts Centre Melbourne, until 28th November, 2026.

Alex First

Other reviews you might enjoy: